BOINC 6.13.10 X64 CPU + GPU usage


Advanced search

Message boards : Cruncher's Corner : BOINC 6.13.10 X64 CPU + GPU usage

AuthorMessage
dunx
Send message
Joined: Aug 13 10
Posts: 118
Credit: 14,287,597
RAC: 20,258
Message 114892 - Posted 13 Nov 2011 12:10:09 UTC

    Well I've woken my fastest PC up after a few months break, and yesterday downloaded BOINC 6.13.10 and the cpu usage was 0.05 CPU per GPU.

    This morning it is 0.2 !

    Strange ?

    dunx

    Profile Bikeman (Heinz-Bernd Eggenstein)
    Forum moderator
    Project administrator
    Project developer
    Avatar
    Send message
    Joined: Aug 28 06
    Posts: 3225
    Credit: 72,750,189
    RAC: 33,664
    Message 114906 - Posted 14 Nov 2011 9:08:13 UTC - in response to Message 114892.

      Well I've woken my fastest PC up after a few months break, and yesterday downloaded BOINC 6.13.10 and the cpu usage was 0.05 CPU per GPU.

      This morning it is 0.2 !

      Strange ?

      dunx


      A CPU usage of 20% for the host and GPU like yours is quite normal for the current batch of GPU tasks at Einstein@Home. Nothing to be concerned about.

      HBE
      ____________

      Profile MarkJ
      Avatar
      Send message
      Joined: Feb 28 08
      Posts: 213
      Credit: 25,059,124
      RAC: 439
      Message 114909 - Posted 14 Nov 2011 13:22:59 UTC - in response to Message 114892.

        Well I've woken my fastest PC up after a few months break, and yesterday downloaded BOINC 6.13.10 and the cpu usage was 0.05 CPU per GPU.

        This morning it is 0.2 !

        Strange ?

        dunx


        Out of interest why would you put 6.13.10 on it?

        Its very much a work in progress version of BOINC. In fact its pretty much been rewritten. Oh and its up to 6.13.12 at the moment. There have been a few fixes since .10 came out.

        dunx
        Send message
        Joined: Aug 13 10
        Posts: 118
        Credit: 14,287,597
        RAC: 20,258
        Message 114914 - Posted 14 Nov 2011 18:27:48 UTC

          Erm....

          Because I can't download software two days into the future !

          dunx

          Claggy
          Send message
          Joined: Dec 29 06
          Posts: 420
          Credit: 913,194
          RAC: 13
          Message 114916 - Posted 14 Nov 2011 19:01:36 UTC - in response to Message 114914.

            Last modified: 14 Nov 2011 19:53:54 UTC

            Erm....

            Because I can't download software two days into the future !

            dunx

            Your first received Wu was at 12th Nov 2011 12:32:06 UTC, 6.13.11 was tagged for release at 10:07 10th Nov 11 (Pacific time i believe), and 6.13.12 was tagged for release at 09:39 11th Nov 11,
            they don't always appear immediately in the download location, normally very soon after.

            http://boinc.berkeley.edu/trac/timeline

            Claggy

            Profile Gary Roberts
            Forum moderator
            Send message
            Joined: Feb 9 05
            Posts: 3004
            Credit: 1,034,231,980
            RAC: 2,425,739
            Message 114918 - Posted 14 Nov 2011 22:59:04 UTC - in response to Message 114914.

              Erm....

              Because I can't download software two days into the future !

              dunx

              I think MarkJ's comment wasn't so much to do with running 6.13.10 instead of 6.13.11 or 6.13.12 but rather why run 6.13.X instead of a more stable (recommended) version? If you want to see an example of the grief that comes from the bleeding edge, take a look at this thread and particularly read Richard Haselgrove's explanation of the problem. If your intention is to help debug BOINC, then fine, but if you're trying to bring a host back to a more stable crunching environment, then you're using the wrong version. I'm pretty sure that was MarkJ's point.

              If you want to use a 'less risky' test version, try to avoid those where new versions are appearing almost every day. If a test version has been around for a week or two, it's probably less likely to contain show stoppers. Also, with test versions, you are supposed to upgrade immediately there is a new release. The BOINC Devs aren't too interested in bug reports from earlier point releases.

              ____________
              Cheers,
              Gary.

              Profile MarkJ
              Avatar
              Send message
              Joined: Feb 28 08
              Posts: 213
              Credit: 25,059,124
              RAC: 439
              Message 114923 - Posted 15 Nov 2011 11:34:07 UTC

                I think Gary has summed it up better than I said it.

                As 6.13 was a rewrite its probably one of the more error-prone versions. The 6.12 versions are more of an incremental change so tend to be more stable.

                My other point was you may have grabbed the 6.13 simply because its the highest version there, without realising its problems.

                Anyway its a major pain to go back to a 6.12 version now (the client_state file isn't backwards compatible without some editing), so you might as well stay with it unless its causing major issues for you.

                I do post the BOINC change history on Seti and GPUgrid so people there can see whats going on with it, but refrain from posting on Einstein as I don't think people here would be interested.

                Richard Haselgrove
                Send message
                Joined: Dec 10 05
                Posts: 1325
                Credit: 29,271,497
                RAC: 11,002
                Message 114924 - Posted 15 Nov 2011 11:56:37 UTC

                  It might be noted that the public test of OpenCL applications - primarily related to ATI GPUs - which Bernd announced yesterday is also testing the new OpenCL detection features in v6.13.12, and the new BOINC server code behind them.

                  (message 114911)

                  dunx
                  Send message
                  Joined: Aug 13 10
                  Posts: 118
                  Credit: 14,287,597
                  RAC: 20,258
                  Message 114931 - Posted 15 Nov 2011 21:45:25 UTC

                    Yup ! signed up for Albert as well !

                    dunx

                    P.S. Been away for a few months and just jumped back in with the most obvious download... ( Don't mind a few problems along the way ! )

                    Fred J. Verster
                    Avatar
                    Send message
                    Joined: Apr 27 08
                    Posts: 114
                    Credit: 20,727,834
                    RAC: 0
                    Message 114939 - Posted 16 Nov 2011 14:57:44 UTC - in response to Message 114931.

                      Last modified: 16 Nov 2011 15:47:34 UTC


                      My other point was you may have grabbed the 6.13 simply because its the highest version there, without realising its problems.

                      Anyway its a major pain to go back to a 6.12 version now (the client_state file isn't backwards compatible without some editing), so you might as well stay with it unless its causing major issues for you.

                      I do post the BOINC change history on Seti and GPUgrid so people there can see whats going on with it, but refrain from posting on Einstein as I don't think people here would be interested.


                      It might be noted that the public test of OpenCL applications - primarily related to ATI GPUs - which Bernd announced yesterday is also testing the new OpenCL detection features in v6.13.12, and the new BOINC server code behind them.


                      (message 114911)



                      As far as I know, CPU usage always was around 10 to 25%, depending
                      on your CPU, brand,type, features, capabillity, also how many GPUs , i.e. a
                      desktop or work-station, a laptop, although differences quickly
                      are dissapearing, atleast getting lessser, always have to use a balance between
                      power and (accu) time.
                      This
                      host,
                      look at some CPU+GPU tasks.

                      And this
                      host,
                      where 0.20CPU and 1 NVIDIA GPU is running those tasks for quite a while now.

                      I want to add, the GPU application has defenatly improved, I wonder what difference or advantage has a FERMI class GPU, over a 8000/9000/200 series of GPUs? Apart from running more then 1 instance per device.

                      By the way, very pleased the search has discovered quite a lot of new pulsars!

                      The version of BOINC has little or no effect on the Project Typical Applications, the science app' s, which are, ofcoarse, two different
                      things. BOINC is a Manger, handling communications, with all projects involved, detecting hardware, how to handle and compute a WU, anonymous app' s involved, among other things.

                      Well, I just had to nreinstall WIN 7, 64BIT, 2 Seagate harddrives gave out.
                      S.M.A.R.T. ALREADY was bad, but a copy and reverse to BOINC 6.10.60
                      from 6.12.34, ended in a mess.

                      And I aplologize to my winmen/women, all of them had to time out, since I
                      also was hospitalized for a week. :-/ Also had to recover and still are.

                      Now that the I7-2600 and 2 EAH5870 and running again and have some 1500GByte
                      of extra storage, BOINC didn't have enough diskspace, cause a piece was already bad and the only ' room' was for a Swap Page.
                      (And CPDN had a staggering 12 GBytes(?) space and 520 hour WUs).
                      And installed SAMSUNG, 1 x 500GB and 2 1TB SATA 2 drives, for a change ;-)

                      I would like to try an OpenCL app. on the ATI (AMD) GPUs, I'll read the forums
                      and there is already a (beta) test?!

                      Do later BOINC version make use of AVX, f.i.? Or the science app.?
                      ____________

                      Knight who says Ni N! N!

                      Profile MarkJ
                      Avatar
                      Send message
                      Joined: Feb 28 08
                      Posts: 213
                      Credit: 25,059,124
                      RAC: 439
                      Message 114958 - Posted 17 Nov 2011 11:26:12 UTC

                        Re: AVX instructions

                        As far as I know only the Seti optimisers have done a version to use it. I don't have a CPU that supports it so haven't checked other projects apart from the ones I normally run. From what I gather it wasn't a simple matter of recompile the app to use it, they had to make some code changes to get a speed advantage.

                        Given its only the newest CPU's that support AVX (latest i7's and AMD bulldozer) then it will take some time before apps start taking advantage.


                        ____________
                        BOINC blog

                        robertmiles
                        Send message
                        Joined: Oct 8 09
                        Posts: 108
                        Credit: 2,448,232
                        RAC: 2,732
                        Message 114983 - Posted 19 Nov 2011 1:27:23 UTC - in response to Message 114939.

                          Last modified: 19 Nov 2011 1:34:00 UTC

                          Fred J. Verster,


                          Well, I just had to nreinstall WIN 7, 64BIT, 2 Seagate harddrives gave out.
                          S.M.A.R.T. ALREADY was bad, but a copy and reverse to BOINC 6.10.60
                          from 6.12.34, ended in a mess.


                          Does that computer happen to be an HP model? If so, you might want to know that, on some models, their S.M.A.R.T. test happens to assume that no other tasks are running, and will appear to fail if you leave BOINC running at the same time.

                          That may cause problems if you then have new hard drives installed without any effort to recover what you can from the old hard drives. It's already happened to me at least a year ago.

                          Post to thread

                          Message boards : Cruncher's Corner : BOINC 6.13.10 X64 CPU + GPU usage


                          Home · Your account · Message boards

                          This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) under Grants PHY-1104902, PHY-1104617 and PHY-1105572 and by the Max Planck Gesellschaft (MPG). Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the investigators and do not necessarily reflect the views of the NSF or the MPG.

                          Copyright © 2014 Bruce Allen