Is there a GPU version of the app in the works?

MarkJ
MarkJ
Joined: 28 Feb 08
Posts: 437
Credit: 137763410
RAC: 17654

Any update on the Einstein

Any update on the Einstein cuda app?

Are you waiting on some other changes (such as boinc upgrades, CUDA 2.2 to settle down, etc) before releasing it for testing?

Anything we can do to help the cause?

Cheers

TamCaP
TamCaP
Joined: 22 Jan 05
Posts: 4
Credit: 4281922
RAC: 0

Is it polite to make a bump

Is it polite to make a bump and a very polite request for some update?

Bernd Machenschalk
Bernd Machenschalk
Moderator
Administrator
Joined: 15 Oct 04
Posts: 4274
Credit: 245314645
RAC: 11979

We are still working on it.

We are still working on it. There is some progress, but we are not done yet. The work on an ABP1 CUDA App is currently a bit ahead of a S5R5 one, so that might come out first, but there is still a lot of work ahead. Please bear with us.

BM

BM

rbpeake
rbpeake
Joined: 18 Jan 05
Posts: 266
Credit: 983939451
RAC: 598839

RE: We are still working on

Message 87193 in response to message 87192

Quote:

We are still working on it. There is some progress, but we are not done yet. The work on an ABP1 CUDA App is currently a bit ahead of a S5R5 one, so that might come out first, but there is still a lot of work ahead. Please bear with us.

BM


This question may not make sense since EAH is hosting the pulsar search, but your comment above brings it to mind. Any thought on enabling the preferences to allow for the ABP search only?

I realize you might risk losing some EAH participants (perhaps), but it seems to me the upside is you would get additional volunteers who would want to crunch the ABP data only.

Just a thought.

Thanks!

John Clark
John Clark
Joined: 4 May 07
Posts: 1087
Credit: 3143193
RAC: 0

It would be nice to see ATI

It would be nice to see ATI Radeon HD 38xx and 48xx GPU clients as well. Milkyway went the ATI route as they needed double precision in their science and the nVidia GTX 2xx series did not meet this requirement. Now there is efforts to make their client CUDA GPU responsive.

Shih-Tzu are clever, cuddly, playful and rule!! Jack Russell are feisty!

Bikeman (Heinz-Bernd Eggenstein)
Bikeman (Heinz-...
Moderator
Joined: 28 Aug 06
Posts: 3522
Credit: 691642530
RAC: 239657

RE: RE: We are still

Message 87195 in response to message 87193

Quote:
Quote:

We are still working on it. There is some progress, but we are not done yet. The work on an ABP1 CUDA App is currently a bit ahead of a S5R5 one, so that might come out first, but there is still a lot of work ahead. Please bear with us.

BM


This question may not make sense since EAH is hosting the pulsar search, but your comment above brings it to mind. Any thought on enabling the preferences to allow for the ABP search only?

No, the fact that you cannot opt-out of the LIGO data processing experiment (currently S5R5) was a deliberate choice. Project management recently decided to keep it this way (discussed in another thread).

CU

Bikeman

Simplex0
Simplex0
Joined: 1 Sep 05
Posts: 152
Credit: 964726
RAC: 0

As BOINC does not support \

As BOINC does not support \ have the skil to write a code that runs on AMD
cards we can only hope for a new Cluster Physik, I wish that he could be cloned :)

At the moment my single HD4870 card spiting out 10X the credit as my Q6600 and i7 put togeather. My creds have skyrocketing from 5000 to 50000 a day.:)

Keap on crawling Einstein ;)

MarkJ
MarkJ
Joined: 28 Feb 08
Posts: 437
Credit: 137763410
RAC: 17654

RE: As BOINC does not

Message 87197 in response to message 87196

Quote:

As BOINC does not support \ have the skil to write a code that runs on AMD
cards we can only hope for a new Cluster Physik, I wish that he could be cloned :)

At the moment my single HD4870 card spiting out 10X the credit as my Q6600 and i7 put togeather. My creds have skyrocketing from 5000 to 50000 a day.:)

Keap on crawling Einstein ;)

You have to remember that Nvidia supplied a couple of cards and the programming expertise to get cuda supported. ATI did not. That is why it isn't currently supported. ATI support is, according to the BOINC roadmap, slated for the 6.10 versions.

While we could debate the merits of either brand the reality is Nvidia put its money where its mouth is and ATI choose not to. If you want your ATI card supported why not ask the executives at ATI to provide resources so that ATI support can be added sooner?

Simplex0
Simplex0
Joined: 1 Sep 05
Posts: 152
Credit: 964726
RAC: 0

It is already supporte by

It is already supporte by Folding@home and I crunch for them also
as they are kapable to write codes for both AMD and NVIDIA.

If BOINC chose to not include the chrunching power of AMD
just becaus they did not provide the card we can
put it to good use outside BOINC thank's to the Stanford group. ;)

Bikeman (Heinz-Bernd Eggenstein)
Bikeman (Heinz-...
Moderator
Joined: 28 Aug 06
Posts: 3522
Credit: 691642530
RAC: 239657

I guess more important than

I guess more important than getting hardware is direct support from NVIDIA experts and driver developers. Both ATI and NVIDIA will support the OpenCL standard in the future and we'll see more cross-GPU-platform projects then, but in the "first round" of GPGPU computing, NVIDIA clearly has offered better support for developers.

CU
Bikeman

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.